The Lathe of Heaven

 THE LATHE OF HEAVEN

Ursula K. Leguin

Books for Bigots

I find it only appropriate that I comment on what I read and for the specific purpose of suggesting, or not suggesting as the case may be, Books for Bigots.  The Lathe of Heaven would be a tough read for most Bigots.  George Orr's dreams change reality - - what he dreams becomes instantly what is.

Another disturbing item is that aliens have arrived, and being peaceful, are being allowed to stay and mingle with the human population.  This, of course, is the worst case scenario for a Bigot in that all Bigots, Bigotry in general, has its basis in sameness.  If you are not like me, be gone.

This "being like me" concept is the basis of all bigotry.  Difference is anathema and the core of all unpleasantness.  In THE LATHE OF HEAVEN, Leguin pretty much hits on all the buttons of difference.  George seeks legal aid from a black, female, attorney who hates the law apparently - - not necessarily a good choice with regard to hating the law, not for the fact of female or black, although there are a good many bigots who would not condone either female or black when it comes to positions of authority or to for assistance in a legal matter.  There are times when you would think that we live in a Muslim country when it comes to the  Bigot view of the responsibilities and duties of the female of the species, not that there aren't female Bigots as well.  Bigotry is not limited to the male sex.

But the main issue here is that when George dreams something it becomes reality affecting everything, including people.  For instance, if several downtown buildings were to be not included in a dream of that section of downtown, they would simply not be there when he awakens (nor the people in them).  Pretty scarcely really, but the most brilliant and exciting method of getting rid of people, including aliens, that one could possibly devise which will appeal to all Bigots instantly.   It is a Bigot fantasy - - to wish it or to dream it and it will be.  Bigotry wishful thinking.

I might have to rethink this book for purposes of recommended reading for Bigots.  In many ways, it would be ideal, in others, however, especially the acceptance of aliens, it might be anathema.  There is a conflict here that may be too much for the average Bigot - - Bigots are uncomfortable with ambiguity and this book has it.  

Certainty has always been a clear prerogative of Bigots; it is one of the trademarks of a Bigot.  Without certainty Bigotry is subject to vacillation which is never a sought for condition.  Hence, I am ambivalent.  The book is an interesting read and holds your interest throughout and has a number of interesting comments that get your attention.  However, weighing all the factors presented here, I will have to say that most Bigots would not enjoy the book.

Richard E H Phelps II

Mingo